Eye makeup plays a huge role in the way you look. So, we have created a list of the best eye-brightening pencils to define your eyes and make them pop. They help elevate your appearance and make you look radiant and attractive. As the skin around your eyes is delicate, they need extra protection and can benefit from some TLC. Whether you want to sport a smokey eye, a classic winged eye, or a cat-eye, eye brightening pencils can do the trick. They also help you shape and highlight your brow bones, giving you eyebrow goals that everyone will love. So, choose your favorite eye brightening pencils from the list below and get some heads turning. Many shades of eye-brightening pencils provide a shimmer and matte effect. We have listed the 11 best eye brightening pencils on the market to brighten your eyes with a single swipe.
11 Best Eye Brightening Pencils
1. Best Waterproof: Maybelline New York Lasting Drama Light Eyeliner
Maybelline’s shiny bronze automatic eye brightening pencil is an extremely long-lasting pencil that gives a shimmery metallic effect and is non-smudge and waterproof. It is a smooth formula with a self-sharpening tip, making it easy to use. It comes in different shades to suit different skin tones. Pros
Glides smoothly Highly pigmented Even consistency Available in a range of luminous shades
Cons
May break easily May clump slightly
2. Best Long-Lasting: Artisan L’uxe Beauty Velvet Jumbo Eyeliner Pencil
Artisan L’uxe’s brightening pencil contains age-defying ceramides and hyaluronic acid to enhance your eye look each time and make your skin firm. It is water-resistant, smudge-proof, and long-lasting. It has a smudge tip on one end to allow you to blend the shimmering bronze shade smoothly over your eyelid. This pencil can give you smoky eyes within minutes, and its organic ingredients such as sunflower seed oil and chamomile extract can moisturize your skin. Learn more about the product in this video. Pros
Dome-shaped Finely-milled Nourishes the delicate area High-density pigments
Cons
May be slightly shimmery Tip may be a bit thick
3. Best Dual-Sided: Anastasia Beverly Hills Highlighting Duo Pencil
Accentuate your eyes with a subtle shimmer or a matte effect with this dual-sided pencil by Anastasia Beverly. For best results, apply the shimmer end and follow it up with the matte end. It smoothly slides across your eyelids, giving your eyes a defining natural finish. Check out this video to learn more about the product. Pros
Non-wax formula Cruelty-free Brightens your eyes Creamy texture
Cons
Tip may be a bit fragile May be a tad greasy
4. Best Pigmented: Lorac Front Of The Line Pro Eye Pencil
Get the desired finish with this Front Of The Line Pro liquid eyeliner by Lorac that is long-lasting, waterproof, and highly pigmented. It gives a uniform matte finish and is available in several metallic shades. This pencil is ophthalmologist-tested and comes with a sharpener. Check out this product review video to learn more. Pros
Retractable pencil Safe for contact lens wearers Can also be used on the waterline Doesn’t irritate the eyes
Cons
May be a bit waxy May dry out pretty quickly
5. Best Smudge-Proof: Pure Ziva Bright Vivid Eyeliner Pencil
Bring home this matte eyeliner by Pure Ziva that is ideal for tight lining. The dermatologically-tested and cruelty-free product gives a defining look to your eyes and eyebrows with a smooth effect and smoothly glides through the skin. The matte ivory wood eye brightener is long-lasting and smudge-proof. Pros
Non-toxic and allergy-tested Ophthalmologist-tested Safe for the contact lens wearer Made with mineral and castor oil Cruelty-free
Cons
Shade may be lighter than you expect May not glide on as smoothly as expected
6. Best Creamy Texture: NYX Professional Makeup Faux Whites Eye Brightener
NYX eyeliner pencil comes in various shades, such as linen, lavender, blush, and mint, and gives a velvety-soft matte effect. This pencil glides on effortlessly across your eyelids, and you can apply the creamy brightener in a single swipe. The product is cruelty-free. Pros
Vegan-friendly Stays put all day long Waterproof Available in different shades
Cons
May be less suitable for the waterline May not be easy to sharpen
7. Best Natural Brightener: Trish McEvoy Eye Brightener Pencil Shell
Trish McEvoy brightening pencil highlights the brow bones effectively, giving you a natural, fresh appearance. It smoothly glides across the eyelids, giving you a defining eye look and a natural, fresh appearance. You can blend the pencil with a laydown brush to obtain a subtle uniform brightening effect. Pros
Creamy texture Bright pale pink shade Free of phthalates and SLS Easy to use
Cons
May be slightly thick May dry out and not last very long
8. Best For All Skin Types: Youngblood Eye-illuminating Duo Pencil
This dual-ended pencil gives a shimmery and matte effect. The shimmer side helps brighten your eyelids, while the matte side helps define your brow bones to give you an attractive, well-defined natural eye look. It is formulated with skin-friendly ingredients and is ideal for most skin types. Pros
Creamy texture Has hydrating properties Non-comedogenic Free of parabens and talc Cruelty-free
Cons
Pigmentation may be less May need frequent reapplication
9. Best Refreshing: Jolie Waterline Liner Eye Brightening Pencil
Give your eyes a refreshing appearance with this pencil by Jolie. It is a waterproof, smudge-proof brightening liner that gives your eyes a natural luster. Its nude shade blends perfectly with your skin. When applied directly to the lower inner rim of your eyes, it makes the eyes look wider and prominent. It is formulated with jojoba oil extracts and does not contain parabens, making your skin soft and smooth. Pros
Transfer-resistant Free of fragrance Stays put all day long Makes your eyes pop
Cons
May fade out soon on the waterline Shade may be lighter than expected
10. Best Fragrance Free: Sorme Cosmetics Brow Lift Highlighting Pencil
Brighten your eyes with this pencil that forms a creamy natural layer around your eyes to give them a youthful, dewy appearance. It is suitable for all skin types and can also be used to define your brow bone and highlight your inner eye corners. It is fragrance-free and easy to apply using a brush or your fingers. Pros
Hydrating formula Enhances eyes Crease- and flake-resistant Doesn’t budge
Cons
Shade may be lighter than expected May be less suitable for darker tones
11. Best Fade-Resistant: Erinde White Eyeliner Pencil
The skin-friendly white eyeliner is waterproof, fade-resistant, and smudge-proof and forms a natural matte layer on your eyelid to define your eyes and brows sharply. Its long-lasting formula and fine tip allow you to highlight your eyes precisely. This set of 12 pieces is suitable for all skin types and is lightweight and portable. Pros
Safe for sensitive skin Suitable for creating dramatic eyes Sweat-proof Hyper-pigmented
Cons
May be a bit hard for the waterline
How To Choose The Right Eye Brightening Pencil?
Before buying an eye-brightening pencil, consider the following factors.
- Shade: Highlighter pencils come in various shades. You can choose the shade depending on your skin tone.
- Finish: Some pencils give a matte effect, while others have a shimmery effect. Some pencils have both. Choose a pencil that is versatile and fits your makeup routine. Eye brightening pencils are a must-have product in your cosmetic kit to obtain flawless eye makeup. They enhance your eye shape and eyebrows by highlight your brow bones and waterline.
Why Trust MomJunction?
Poulami Nag, the writer of this post, has a knack for reviewing beauty and personal care products. She has rounded up this list of the best eye brightening pencils available online. Poulami has done in-depth research to ensure you purchase high-quality products that contain safe ingredients and are water-resistant, smudge-proof, and long-lasting. Further, she gives you useful tips on choosing the most suitable product that can help you accentuate your eyes.
Recommended Articles:
Best White Eyeliners Best White Pens Best Gel Eyeliners For Long-Lasting
